GAME CLASSICS
[Since our early days, we have enjoyed highlighting great games that, for one reason or another, only lasted for a relatively short time on the gaming stage despite exceptional qualities. In some cases, we've reached back decades to shed some light on great games but greatness is not the sole province of the distant past. Sometimes, it's much more recent - as in this case.
At this year's International Toy Fair, I spoke with a representative from the company that produced this issue's Game Classic. I mentioned how terrific this game was and wondered why it didn't have a longer shelf life. He agreed with me about the game's merits but apparently "conventional wisdom" decreed the game "too difficult" to enjoy sustained success. I completely disagreed - now and then. Back when it was released, we recognized its quality and featured it in our pages. But the last word always belongs to the customers and, unfortunately, this game, despite achieving critical success including a nomination for the coveted Spiel de Jahres award, soon vanished from the marketplace. In this installment of Game Classics, we revisit our take on this quality game by reprinting the original review by Steve Kurzban (aka Kban) from the Summer 1998 GA REPORT as this classic claims an honored place in our own Hall of Fame: Tycoon.]
TYCOON (Jumbo, 1998, 2 to 4 players, ages 10 and up, about 90 minutes; out of print)
As designed by Wolfgang Kramer and Horst-Rainer Rösner, Tycoon is a business game of building hotels and factories in nine different cities. Each player starts the game with an airplane, six hotels, five factories and $15 million in starting capital. The game consists of three paydays, each triggered when one player has built his 6th 12th and 18th hotel.
Before dismissing Tycoon
as being yet another variation in the Acquire
genre. note that it has several novel mechanisms and twists that mesh together
quite well to produce a unique gaming experience that its very worthy of its
1998 German Game of the Year nomination.
In Tycoon, players purchase airline tickets of two varieties: expensive direct schedule flights to or from the named city or less expensive charter flights between two cities. The more expensive direct flight tickets may also be used to move a space (or more) around the board giving a player greater flexibility in movement (and justifying their additional cost). Two of the direct flight tickets and six of the charter tickets are turned face-up. On a player's turn, he can buy as many tickets as finances allow. Tickets are then replenished in the same 2/6 ratio. The player then can stay put and erect a hotel or factory there. There are only two landing spaces in each city; if the first one is occupied, the second player is forced to spend more to build a hotel or factory at that site.
As hotels are added to a city, payoffs for first and second place holdings (i.e. the number of hotels) increase and eventually decrease! (The economic concept of diminishing returns is finally realized in a boardgame.) When a key red space is covered by a hotel, the first hotel built in that city must be "renovated". Renovation results in the hotel moved off the track (and placed in the city "center") so that it no longer counts towards ownership of a chain in that city. To put the hotel back in play, the player must eventually fly back to that city, which allows him to place the hotel, for free, on the next available space in the chain!
Factories are more expensive than hotels but guarantee a second place payoff on each payday and a first place payoff if the factory is built in the city with the longest hotel chain. Players receive six hotels per round but have only five factories for the entire game.
Money in Tycoon is very dear. The starting capital is totally inadequate for both building six hotels (and/or factories) and buying airline tickets. As a result, one must fly off-board to one's home bank to take out small ($10 million) or large ($16 million) loans. Returning to the board requires an expensive direct flight ticket. In our playtesting sessions, al our players have concluded that taking out a loan on your first turn is virtually mandatory.
When one player has built his sixth hotel, it's payday. The other players who have yet to complete that round get one more turn, ensuring that everyone has had an identical number of turns. We've added a rule: rotation clockwise of the first player for each round to partially negate the advantage of being last in a round. Each city is then scored by paying the player with the most hotels in a city the bonus for first place with second place earning roughly half as much. Factory bonuses are then paid in the same fashion. The final payout is for diveristy. Players get increasingly more money for each city where they have hotels (according to a chart on the game board). Loans are then repaid (or rolled over at greater cost) and each player receives six more hotels. After the third payday, all remaining loans are repaid and players add up their remaining money. The richest player wins!
The scoring system of Tycoon rewards both a player's dominance in a particular city and the breadth of his holdings. This duality makes for painful choices which have a direct effect on the final outcome. The only luck factor here is the ticket availability. Watching your opponents' moves and reacting accordingly is crucial to eventual victory or defeat. Tycoon is a delectable balancing act that impresses me more each time I play. Among 1998's Spiel des Jahres nominees, Tycoon has become our group's favorite. Highly recommended. -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Steve Kurzban
copyright © 1998, all rights reserved.
BattleLore Catan Histories: Struggle for Rome Doodle Dice Editorial
HeroCard: Rise of the Shogun Kill Doctor Lucky Midgard